Appraisal of Dimensional Accuracy in Five Brands of Extended Pour Irreversible Hydrocolloid Materials for FDP Impression


  • Upasana Panda
  • Mirna Garhnayak
  • Gunjan Srivastava
  • Gopal Choudhury
  • Pradyumna Ku. Sahoo
  • Sangram Panda



Extended pour irreversible hydrocolloid; Dimensional accuracy; FDP


Aim. The purpose of this study was to assess and compare the dimensional accuracies of five brands of
extended pour irreversible hydrocolloid materials for fixed dental prosthesis impression.
Materials and methods. Impressions of a master stainless steel model were made with five extended pour
irreversible hydrocolloids and one addition silicone impression material. A total of ninety impressions
(n=90) were made, with fifteen for each group of impression material. The stone dies retrieved from
these impressions were analysed with Baty-Vision Systems - Venture 3D CNC machine, for dimensional
accuracies. Comparison of continuous data between two groups was done with the Wilcoxon rank-sum test
(Mann Whitney U test) and for more than two groups with the Kruskal Wallis test (? = .05)
Results. All six impression materials showed some amount of error. On comparison of the median total
absolute deviation of the various dimension of stone dies, the accuracies of impression materials in decreasing
order appeared to be Neocolloid >> Affinis >> Coltoprint >> Zelgan >> 3M ESPE >> Plastalgin. On the
contrary, a comparison of the impression materials, in terms of several dimensions of stone dies differing
significantly from the stainless-steel model, the sequence in terms of accuracy was, Coltoprint > Affinis >3M
ESPE > Neocolloid > Plastalgin > Zelgan.
Conclusions. Based on the dimensional accuracies of the stone dies retrieved from the impressions,
Neocolloid was found to be the best impression material with the least possible deviation, followed by
Coltoprint and Affinis.

Author Biographies

Upasana Panda

Postgraduate Student

Mirna Garhnayak


Gunjan Srivastava


Gopal Choudhury


Pradyumna Ku. Sahoo

Associate Professor

Sangram Panda

Associate Professor, Department
of Prosthodontics, Institute of Dental Sciences, Siksha ‘O’ Anusandhan, (Deemed to be University), Bhubaneswar,
Odisha, India



How to Cite

Upasana Panda, Mirna Garhnayak, Gunjan Srivastava, Gopal Choudhury, Pradyumna Ku. Sahoo, & Sangram Panda. (2021). Appraisal of Dimensional Accuracy in Five Brands of Extended Pour Irreversible Hydrocolloid Materials for FDP Impression. Indian Journal of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology, 15(2), 3955-3963.

Most read articles by the same author(s)